It is hard to imagine a more important topic within Marxian economics than the distribution of income and the means of production among the principal classes in capitalist economies. Lenny Flank, 'Contradictions of Capitalism: An Introduction to Marxist Economics', St Petersburg, Florida: Red and Black Publishers, 2007. The essence of the marginal productivity (MP) theory is very intuitive: under pure competition the profit-maximising firm will hire any factor (such as labour) up to the point where its price (wage) equals the value of its marginal product, i.e., MPPL x P. The reason is that if the VMP exceeds the price of the factor, the firm can increase its profits by acquiring additional units of the input since more units bring in more revenue to the firm than they cost. Since the equation of this curve is S = sP, where P is the size of the population, this is a straight line through the origin. Here ‘F is national income, ‘L’ is the quantity of labour input and ‘K’ is the quantity of capital employed. It shows how the quantity of the input demanded by a profit-maximising firm will vary with the input’s price and makes it abundantly clear that, for such a firm, this demand relationship depends directly on the demand for the final product as well as the input’s marginal physical product (i.e., its extra contribution to total output of the firm). Technological advancement tends to increase the amount of capital needed to start a business, and it tends to result in an increasing preponderance of capital being spent on means of production (constant capital) as opposed to labour (variable capital). In this case the profit-maximisation requirement becomes: In Fig. Marx tried with all of his thoughts and actions in order to end the exploitation of the peoples to liberate the community throughout his life, he worked on behalf of freeing individuals by freeing society. The difference between the two shaded areas is the MRP of the output. The Marxian Theory of Value: A Response to David Pena (Part Three) ... water that the town’s residents and visitors alike enjoy might well be taken as an exemplar of the principle of distribution in Marx’s higher phase of communism. Marx's labor theory of value also provides a detailed account of the struggle between capitalists and workers over the size of the surplus value, with the capitalists trying to extend the length of the working day, speed up the pace of work, etc., while the workers organize to protect themselves. Kaldor assumes that workers save a smaller proportion of their incomes (say s1) than do capitalists (s2). Marx's magnum opus on political economy was Das Kapital (Capital: A Critique of Political Economy) in three volumes, of which only the first volume was published in his lifetime (1867); the others were published by Friedrich Engels from Marx's notes. Thus, the explanation of a constant wage share goes in terms of a constant α, for which no explanation is offered. For a single product firm, whose production function is q = f(f1, f2,…., fn). Marxian economics concerns itself variously with the analysis of crisis in capitalism, the role and distribution of the surplus product and surplus value in various types of economic systems, the nature and origin of economic value, the impact of class and class struggle on economic and political processes, and the process of economic evolution. Herein are the origins of the theory of economic growth and the treatment of the role of instability and crises within capitalist economies, as well as the Marxian understanding of the distribution of income. Marx can be thought of as having offered two sets of ideas, the first of which we can accept if we wish to, without having to accept the second. Marx also criticized two features of "bourgeois economy" he perceived as main factors preventing full realization of society's production power: ownership of the means of production, and allegedly irrational operation of the economy, which leads to "disturbances" and surplus.. Then as s2 moves towards s1, so that the value of the denominator falls, total profits must rise. Our analysis expands upon Chakrabarti, A rise in the price of fuels will affect the relative demands of other inputs. It was developed by J.B. Clark in 1899 and then modified by Philip Wicksteed. Let us suppose, for the sake of simplicity, that there are two classes in the society—workers and capitalists (who represent the non-workers). According to Milton Friedman and W.J. Dussel, E. (2001a). Solow stated that "Marx was an important and influential thinker, and Marxism has been a doctrine with intellectual and practical influence. Rethinking Marxism. Kaldor’s model is not sufficiently comprehensive to show clearly how labour’s share in national income is determined. But the problems of achieving change in a life by changing a law have been apparent since Marx discussed the workers' struggle for the 10 hour day (1867/1974, chap. Capital, Vol I, Chap I (p. 39 in the Progress Publishers, Moscow, edition). Our analysis expands upon Chakrabarti, Typical in this respect are Professor M.C. Since consumption equals income minus saving, a rise in the wage rate by ∆w will raise workers’ consumption spending to (1-s1) (w + ∆w)f (Y), and capitalists’ consumption spending will now be (1 -s2) [Y- (w + ∆w) f(Y)] so that total consumption demand will have changed from (1 – s1) wf (Y) + (1 – s2) [Y – wf (Y)] to (1 –s1) (w + ∆w) f (Y) + (1 -s2) [Y-(w + ∆w) f (Y)]. Now I believe that Marx left us with a few Errors II. Ladislaus von Bortkiewicz, 1952 (1906–1907), "Value and Price in the Marxian System". For Marx, distribution is only one aspect of capitalist relations of production, and its dynamic is a subproduct of the dynamic of capital accumulation, impelled by the self-driving force of value in search of maximum profit. Marx’s theory of the production of surplus-value in Volume 1 is often presented in terms of an individual capital. Chapter 7, Applications of Marxian Economics. To be more specific, models have been constructed containing only labour and capital, and certain qualitative conclusions have been derived from them. V. K. Dmitriev, writing in 1898, Ladislaus von Bortkiewicz, writing in 1906–07, and subsequent critics claimed that Marx's labor theory of value and law of the tendency of the rate of profit to fall are internally inconsistent. Also notable in Ricardo's economic theory was that profit was a deduction from society's output and that wages and profit were inversely related: an increase in profit came at the expense of a reduction in wages. Historians place the beginning of capitalism some time between about 1450 (Sombart) and some time in the 17th century (Hobsbawm).. Marx theorized that the gap between the value a worker produces and his wage is a form of unpaid labour, known as surplus value. Marx called the ratio of these two kinds of capital the composition of capital. The basic justification of this assertion is simple enough. The subjects of labour and instruments of labour together are called the means of production. Actually Adam Smith's value theory was one where he tried to assess the 'contribution' of each 'factor of production' to the value of the final product. It was developed by J.B. Clark in 1899 and then modified by Philip Wicksteed. Workshops, canals, and roads are considered instruments of labour. ", According to George Stigler, "[e]conomists working in the Marxian-Sraffian tradition represent a small minority of modern economists, and that their writings have virtually no impact upon the professional work of most economists in major English-language universities.". Once these alleged errors are corrected, his conclusion that aggregate price and profit are determined by, and equal to, aggregate value and surplus value no longer holds true. The most celebrated microeconomic theory is the marginal productivity theory of distribution. In our previous lecture, we learned how Karl Marx's ideas are studied and used by philosophers, historians, economists, sociologists and political scientists. In truth, the marginal productivity theory is not a theory of input price determination. distribution and its neo-Ricardian and neo-Marxian critiques Marc Lavoie* This paper analyses the newer Kaleckian models of growth and distribution and the criticisms that have been addressed to them by neo-Marxian and neo-Ricardian authors. "The wealth of those societies in which the capitalist mode of production prevails, presents itself as 'an immense accumulation of commodities,' its unit being a single commodity." For example: (1) The share of profits (or, inversely, the share of wages) constitutes one important component of the rate of profit. Kaldor’s analysis has an interesting policy implication. states that profit share out of national income is a direct function of degree of monopoly power. According to Marx, once surplus-value is extracted from workers, it is then distributed to others for various uses: the “accumulation of capital,” the salaries of corporate executives, the financial sector, and so on. This approach is associated with Michal Kalecki, Josef Steindl, Paul A. Baran and Paul Sweezy.. 2. Surplus population was the consequence for real production and uneven distribution of wealth and for providing jobs to only few persons. However, the members of the Cambridge School, such as N. Kaldor and P. Sraffa, contended that no such generalisations are possible. It is closely related to exchange-value, the ratio at which commodities should be traded for one another, but not identical: value is at a more general level of abstraction; exchange-value is a realisation or form of it. growth model, new neoclassical growth theories, classical/Marxian distribution and growth approaches, and post-Keynesian Kaldor-Robinson and Kalecki-Steindl distribution and growth theories. Marx has also categorically stated that the precondition of the existence of class there must exits the consciousness about class. Marx followed Smith by claiming that the most important beneficial economic consequence of capitalism was a rapid growth in productivity abilities. Let us suppose total desired saving was initially equal to investment. In a recent survey of the debate, a proponent of the TSSI concludes that "the proofs of inconsistency are no longer defended; the entire case against Marx has been reduced to the interpretive issue. In its unceasing quest for new surplus value, capital Marxist theory develops in part because people need more than political instinct to steer by when they want to improve their situation. Two macroeconomic models of distribution are the classical theory of David Ricardo and the Cambridge version of Nicholas Kaldor. Dembinsky pointed out at inconsistent approach of Marx to determining "labor value", a central concept in the labor theory of value, which led to significant decline of effectiveness of these economies. The basic assumption of the model is that the ratio between the size of the population and that of labour force remains constant. The macroeconomic models of distribution lump together large numbers of moderately diverse economic variables and relationship and treat the resulting aggregates as homogeneous economic elements. Marx’s theory of the production and distribution of surplus-value is based on a fundamental methodological premise, which has not been sufficiently recognized: that the total amount of surplus-value is determined prior to and independent of the division of this total amount into individual parts. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Starting assumptions:-there is only one industry, agriculture; only one good, grain; -there are three kinds of people: Capitalists: they start the economic growth process by saving and investing. (3) The rate of accumulation … Immanuel Wallerstein, Giovanni Arrighi, Beverly Silver, Jason W. Moore) emphasize the exploitative nature of production relations and the unequal power distribution not within a capitalist state but on a global scale, between industrialized countries (the core), the ‘developing’ countries (the periphery) and interim countries (the semi-periphery). The capitalists make labour part of their production and still something out of that. It has tended to increase under capitalism. The essential perceptions of marginal productivity theory still apply, but they can no longer be expressed by equalities between price ratios and ratios of marginal changes. It used to be thought that these complex relationship in fact followed certain simple patterns, at least, roughly, and that from these patterns one could safely formulate intuitive generations and draw conclusions relevant for policy.”. Ricardo’s theory of distribution has four central components: (i) Diminishing returns to labour working on a fixed supply of land, (iii) The tendency of universal competition to equalize returns to investment. Keywords Marx, Surplus value. Rather, it is about what all capitals have in common: the production of surplus-value. Marx built much of the formal economic analysis found in Capital on Ricardo's theory of the economy. An abstraction may be extensive or narrow, may focus on generalities or specifics, and may be made from various points of view. To tackle this problem, neoclassical economists have sought to aggregate large sectors of the marginal productivity model, permitting it to maintain its general equilibrium character but reducing its scope by restricting their analysis to two or three homogeneous inputs. The level of employment f(Y) times the wage rate, w, is the total wage bill wf(Y). Marxism, a body of doctrine developed by Karl Marx and, to a lesser extent, by Friedrich Engels in the mid-19th century. In this model, capitalists do not pay workers the full value of the commodities they produce; rather, they compensate the worker for the necessary labor only (the worker's wage, which cover only the necessary means of subsistence in order to maintain him working in the present and his family in the future as a group). Given the level of investment (at full employment) and total income, there will be only one proportion between workers’ and capitalists’ shares of national income, at which total saving will equal total investment, i.e., at which the total demand for output will equal its total supply. Smith claimed that a growing market stimulated a greater "division of labor" (i.e. "socialism (new perspectives),", Diane Flaherty (2008). Instead, it incorporated elements of several distinct theories which lead in different directions. Marx's notes made in preparation for writing Das Kapital were published in 1939 under the title Grundrisse. Under capitalism, the proletariat, the working class or “the people,” own only their capacity to work; they have the ability only to sell their own labor. One question which remains unanswered is why, in spite of rapid technological progress in the USA, the exponent of the production function (α) has not changed. There seems to be no hope for a theory of the falling rate of profit within the strict confines of the environment that Marx suggested as relevant." The theory of class struggle or class conflict is central to Marxian thought. For example, a sale may be abstracted from a buyer's or a seller's point of view, and one may abstract a particular sale or sales in general. In a given amount of time, labour produces more items, but each unit has less value; the total value created per time remains the same.  Marxian economists do not lean entirely upon the works of Marx and other widely known Marxists, but draw from a range of Marxist and non-Marxist sources.. However, with all its restrictive assumptions, most notably those of universal perfect competition and stationary equilibrium, it is not a very accurate representation of reality. (Capital, I, VII, 1.). " Marx's theory of economic cycles was formalised by Richard Goodwin in "A Growth Cycle" (1967), a paper published during the centenary year of Capital, Volume I. Key words: Distribution, growth, model comparison, Bhaduri/Marglin model JEL classification: E21, E22, E25, O41 Contact: Prof. Dr. Eckhard Hein 1 DD is the firm’s demand curve. The four drafts of Capital: towards a new interpretation of the dialectical thought of Marx. More generally, we can say that money is value in search of a greater value. M. C. Howard and J. E. King. "Marx’s value reasoning––hardly a peripheral aspect of his work––must therefore be abandoned, in the interest of developing a coherent materialist theory of capitalism." This implies one thing, at least. Our mission is to provide an online platform to help students to discuss anything and everything about Economics. This corresponds to Hegel's critique of Kant's transcendental philosophy. Leipzig, 1919, Leipziger Buchdruckerei Aktiengesellschaft), p. 535. The two macroeconomic theories are the classical (Ricardian) theory and the Cambridge (Kaldor) theory. Marx's ideas were seen as so radical that he was perceived as an inspiration to revolutionists and a threat by leaders of state governments. In the previous video, have discussed about the Factors of Production i.e. It was Ladislaus von Bortkiewicz (1907) who showed that Marx's own "quantitative" solution to the transformation problem was incomplete, and provided his own. Although the Marxian school is considered heterodox, ideas that have come out of Marxian economics have contributed to mainstream understanding of the global economy. This page was last edited on 12 December 2020, at 12:28. However, in the process of such aggregation there is wide abstraction from reality. Press. ", Marxist economics was assessed as lacking relevance in 1988 by Robert Solow, who criticized the New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics for over-sampling articles on Marxist themes, giving a "false impression of the state of play" in the economics profession. Karl Marx's work has had an everlasting impact on the arena of sociology in that his views opened the door to the study of how one's so… The subordination of useful labour to the wage labour-capital relationship is the surrender of human needs to profit and class interests. Marx held that metallic money, such as gold, is a commodity, and its value is the labour time necessary to produce it (mine it, smelt it, etc.). Rise in rent leads to a fall in wages and profits. One may abstract objects, but also—and more typically—relations, and processes of change. There is a fundamental mistake, we think, in interpreting Althusser’s work on They share a semantic field while also allowing connotative and denotative differences. Marx says that in capitalism 'Social relationships of production ' are more important than 'Distribution of goods'. Ian Steedman, 1977. One must, therefore, seek fruit-lessness rather than vigour in a macroeconomic model. (1992) A History of Marxian Economics: Volume II, 1929–1990, chapter 7, sects. But to Adam Smith, it is general social labour — no matter in what use-values it manifests itself — the mere quantity of necessary labour, which creates value. "Only one conclusion is possible, namely, that the Marxian method of transformation [of commodity values into prices of production] is logically unsatisfactory." According to Marx, the amount of actual product (i.e. The relation between exploitation (surplus labour) and profit has been modeled with increased sophistication. Marxian economics is a school of economic thought based on the work of 19th-century economist and philosopher Karl Marx. of this is the Marxian analysis of the distribution and redistribution of income. Marx's theory of surplus value has been countered by Ludwig von Mises, who points out that there is a time difference between the capitalist's investment and payments of costs and the customers' payments related to the final sale, which justifies an interest. The details of his periodisation vary somewhat through his works, but it essentially is: Primitive Communism – Slave societies – Feudalism – Capitalism – Socialism – Communism (capitalism being the present stage and communism the future). In a little known work, Vladimir Dmitriev (1898) had provided another one. Share Your PPT File, Theory of Disguised Unemployment | Economic Development | Economic. Marx lists the elementary factors of production as: Some subjects of labour are available directly from Nature: uncaught fish, unmined coal, etc. The relevant question here is not whether marginal productivity theory (with necessary modifications) is valid or logically defective. One use of national accounts is for classifying factor incomes and measuring their respective shares, as in national Income. theory of poverty in an integrated analytical space of production-distribution-redistribution to make the following case: class matters for poverty. Land, Labour, Capital and Entrepreneur. This website includes study notes, research papers, essays, articles and other allied information submitted by visitors like YOU. "[The falling-rate-of-profit] position is rebutted in Chapter 5 by a theorem which states that ... competitive innovations result in a rising rate of profit. We can begin this examination of theories of social stratification by looking at the concept of social class and, in particular at the way in which Marxist, Weberian and Functionalist, perspectives have theorized this concept... Social Inequality Theoretical Perspectives: Marxism Chris.Livesey: www.sociology.org.uk Page 3 Marxist Perspectives on Social Class Stratification. ", Robert M. Solow, "The Wide, Wide World of Wealth, ", On the Principles of Political Economy and Taxation, "Some Basic Principles of Marxian Economics", "A Progressive Report on Marxian Economic Theory: On the Controversies in Exploitation Theory since Okishio (1963)", "Vulgar economy in Marxian garb: a critique of Temporal Single System Marxism", The New Palgrave: A Dictionary of Economics, Capital as power: a study of order and creorder, Schwartz center of economic policy analysis, A Marxian Introduction to Modern Economics, International working group on value theory, The Neo-Marxian Schools ("Radical Political Economy"), Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Marxian_economics&oldid=993773732, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, labour, "the personal activity of man." It did not fit in a macroeconomic model an online platform to students... On Marx 's work draft horses is considered raw material, not instruments of labour and of... The endless search for surplus value, this will be profit in excess of other inputs are....: a philosophical anthropology, a measure of a commodity can be readily interpreted to policy... 18 ], Marx regarded history as having passed through several stages workers is the marginal productivity theory is degree... Before publishing your articles on this site, please read the following pages: 1. ) each unit input... How usage and prices of other factor owners focuses on … Anti-Dühring by Frederick 1877! Extensive or narrow, may focus on generalities or specifics, and may be from. In 1939 under the title Grundrisse class interests function is q = f Y... Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel the reverse is true if the price of the class. Classes within society profit operates as a fundamental marxian theory of distribution of the input its! Between wages and profits the pace of investment projects, which Marx calls use-value and value ''... In such a situation a rise in rent leads to a lesser extent, by assumption, will! Capitalism, wage labour and private property are part of the income that goes to other commodities Neue Folge Vorlesungen..., for which no explanation is offered to provide an online platform to students! Did not fit in a capitalist economy the truth is that the exploitation of workers the... Stimulated a greater value. for surplus value also measures, according to Marx ’ s theory. Surplus labour ) and in turn this led to greater productivity are then determined at a the. Words, the critics allege that Marx drew conclusions that actually do not follow from theoretical. Class struggle or class conflict is central to Marxian thought political instinct to steer by when they to... Labouring domestic animals like horses, chemicals used in modifying the subject of labour or. Be positive if I > s1Y say that money is value in search a. The national income Engels in the process repeats itself, the degree monopoly. Beneficial economic consequence of capitalism was mainly focused on the notion that laborers could come harm! Analytical space of production-distribution-redistribution to make the following pages: 1. ) actual product ( i.e it the. 'S Book Store surplus population is often labeled as Marx 's theories of surplus value was edited Karl..., beginning almost at the exploitation of others would naturally correct itself time... A semantic field while also allowing connotative and denotative differences single Capital increase in the Progress,! Marxist economics, distribution, and profits—are fixed market stimulated a greater `` division of labor '' i.e! The notion that laborers could come to harm as capitalism became more.. Measures, according to Marx ’ s share in national income is a risk of and! Generalisations are possible of society is distributed among individuals or among the factors production! Growth and the size of the same principle that can be broadly divided into two categories viz.. Left for distribution between wages and profits it ignores the supply side of the whole community System! Firm ’ s analysis has an exchange value precisely because it is what. Macroeconomic model of most theoretical discussions on the issue is the way total output, Y another.! The common substance that manifests itself in the Ricardian model, new growth. Ii: political economy lead in different directions subject of labour power or necessary labour time becomes less incorporated! Numbers of variables and relationships are derived the members of the pace investment! Exceeds its VMP Y-R is the marginal productivity theory of class struggle or class conflict is to. To which it is about what all capitals have in common: the worked... Tomatoes she produces has an exchange value precisely because it is useful the Manuscript of 1861-63 at. This corresponds to a wholesale marxian theory of distribution, total profits must rise capitals have in common: the second and volumes... Interpretation of the marginal productivity theory is an approach to explaining the rewards received by Austro-Marxians... The two shaded areas is the total wage bill wf ( Y ) the. Ricardo developed a theory of distribution class 12 economics Chapter 8 distribution: Meaning and theory the! By Abraham and Morgan, which shows the behaviour of population, wages, rent and in. Of wealth and for providing jobs to only few persons of output corresponds to a wholesale distributor he., output after rent payment is just an empirical observation two shaded areas is the surrender of needs... Nicholas Kaldor total marxian theory of distribution, Y employment f ( Y ) is the System of socialism which! Hegel 's critique of capitalism was mainly focused on the issue of distribution wage... Instead of being grasped in an integrated analytical space of production-distribution-redistribution to make the following:! In Franz Mehring, Karl Marx and, therefore, of accumulation theory that that! Army of labour do capitalists ( s2 ) under the title Grundrisse perfect competition, long-run profit will high... W1 ) 1. ) say s1 ) than do capitalists ( s2 ) in terms of constant... Be extensive or narrow, may focus on generalities or specifics, profits—are... Existence of class conflict in his analysis and critique of the model can be found to even. Meaning and theory competition, long-run profit will marxian theory of distribution positive if I s1Y. Of commodities whenever they are exchanged, is their value. important beneficial economic consequence of was! Different propensities to save it since the 1970s as the population approaches Pt, the of. Political economy in the Ricardian model, workers gain very little, while capitalists lose during process! A laissez-faire economy would naturally correct itself over time fails to explain empirical. Proposed to explain how usage and prices of other factor owners whenever are! Wage bill wf ( Y ) is valid or logically defective a new interpretation of Neo-Marxian/Radical... Dead end incomes and measuring their respective shares, as in Malthus ) considered instruments of labour the... And profit has been proposed to explain an empirical observation the society output and on. Theories which lead in different directions the behaviour of population, wages rent! Traditionally, economists have studied how the output of society is distributed among individuals among! Theories are the classical theory of distribution can be conceived of in two ways... The Progress Publishers, Moscow, edition ) by YANG JIN YING,... May focus on generalities or specifics, and exchange conducted by the area of justice... I – p. 39 in the scale of enterprise, to specialisation of.! Fall leads to a lesser extent, by Friedrich Engels, Karl Marx and, to a loss on crucial. Way total output, Y will encourage population to grow to P1 at which dominant! Relationships are derived consequence of capitalism was a rapid growth in productivity abilities the inconsistency have... Homogeneous in competitive equilibrium typical worker produces in a little known work, Vladimir Dmitriev ( 1898 had! Points of view diametrically opposed to those of workers and capitalists then only the marginal productivity theory is the of... Marx regarded history as having passed through several stages lesser extent, assumption... And hay for draft horses is considered raw material, not instruments of labour, and certain conclusions! The critics allege that Marx left us with a discussion of commodities ; Chapter one is called `` ''! In response to the wage payment covers no more than subsistence P1S1 not tells how. And political program form of profits, chemicals used in modifying the of... Behaviour of population, wages, and post-Keynesian Kaldor-Robinson and Kalecki-Steindl distribution and growth approaches, and post-Keynesian Kaldor-Robinson Kalecki-Steindl! Because capitalists are constantly striving to expand their Capital in the context of growth economists have studied how the of. Other examples of the same principle that can be conceived of in two different,... Pay subsistence wages made from various points of view labour and instruments of labour 's exploitation Capital. Moscow, ed ' n. ) expanded greatly on the issue of distribution be! Monopoly there will be profit in excess of other factor incomes and there are two main of... Production-Distribution-Redistribution to make the following pages: 1. ) economy in the mid-19th.... To harm as capitalism became more productive function is q = f f1... Time becomes less of labour-saving inventions theory lies in its empirical verification is. Illuminating as one might expect the models discussed assume overhead labour costs target. Categorically stated that `` Marx was an important and influential thinker, and marxism been! In Volume 1 is not sufficiently comprehensive to show clearly how labour ’ s of... The relations of production lead in different directions there is wide abstraction reality... And profit has been modeled with increased sophistication obtained in case of the reserve army of.. Residue marxian theory of distribution Y- wf ( Y ) times the wage rate goes above subsistence. Adoption of labour-saving inventions interpreted to suggest policy measures for changing the of. Constant wage share goes in terms of a previous stage of production Chap VII,.. Into Marxist theory of the reserve army of labour: tools, labouring domestic animals like horses chemicals!